The purpose of this blog is to help you get your head out of the sand. Please print and share.
Originally this was going to be a very short email:
"Sewage backup this week. Life is good. Shabbat Shalom."
After this week's journey, that's really all that I had in me to write.
But as I was about to send it, the following story appeared in my inbox.
It shows the power of one. It shows the power of vision. It shows the
power of perseverence. It shows how a tragedy can lead to blessing.
And it shows the importance of putting life's challenges into the right perspective.
Alisa Flatow grew up in West Orange, NJ and attended Brandeis University in the mid-1990s.
She chose to spend the spring semester of 1995 studying in Jerusalem. On
April 9, a Sunday morning, she and her roommates hopped on a bus to
visit the beach resort in Gaza.
This was soon after the
Oslo accords, and Gaza was still under Israeli control. It seems unfathomable now, but people used to vacation in Gaza at the beach resorts.
En route to the beach, a man rammed the bus with his van. As the
collision occurred, he flipped a switch on the steering column which
detonated a bomb. Seven Jews on the bus were killed.
53 others on the bus were wounded, including Alisa. The van was filled
with shrapnel that exploded through the windows of the bus and struck
her head. She was unconscious, but her body was unharmed.
The doctors called her father in America and told him to come right
away. When he landed in Ben Gurion airport, government agents met him on
the runway, and escorted him straight from the plane to the hospital.
By the time he arrived, Alisa was brain-dead. The doctors offered their
condolences and asked the father if he would be willing to donate her
organs.
This was not a simple question. The Flatow family was Orthodox and
observant. It was not customary for Orthodox Jews to donate organs, and
they were not sure it was allowed by Jewish law. So the parents called
their rabbi and asked what to do. He told them to donate the organs, and
so they did.
That single act became a sensation in Israel.
Background: there is much in Jewish law and custom that would discourage organ donation.
It has been our longstanding tradition to treat a dead body as sacred.
Our custom is to watch over it, cleanse it, and prepare it carefully for
burial. The body is buried whole and unaltered. That is why rabbinic
authorities have generally discouraged autopsies.
But organ
donation is special. It presents the opportunity to save a life. In
Jewish law, the saving of a human life takes special precedence. You can
violate just about all the other commandments if you can save a life.
Therefore, some believe that Jewish law not only allows organ donation,
it requires it.
The problem was that most Jews in Israel were not aware of this. The
rates of organ donation were extraordinarily low. Israel was part of a
European consortium of organ sharing nations, but was suspended because
too few Israelis were registered donors. It was a stunning irony for a
nation famous as an innovator of advanced medical technologies. The
problem was that Israelis knew about the tradition of burying a body
whole; they were not so aware that their rabbis allowed organ donation.
Throughout the 1970s and 80s, various medical groups and the government
in Israel tried to educate the public, but nothing worked. Organ
donation rates were terribly low. People were desperate for organs, but
few were donating. It just wasn’t what people did.
And then the Flatows offered their daughter’s organs to the people of
Israel. The news made headlines in every newspaper throughout the
nation. Her heart, lungs, liver, kidneys, pancreas, and corneas were
able to save six lives in Israel. Notably, at least one of the
recipients was Arab Palestinian. The people of Israel were amazed, and
grateful. They had felt so alone in suffering against terrorism, and
here this family from America made such a gesture. They felt that the
world Jewish community was with them. We were one.
Days later, Prime Minister Yitzchak Rabin came to Washington DC and
addressed a gathering of 12,000 American supporters of Israel.
He warned about the danger of radical Islam and the role of Iran in
sponsoring it worldwide. He also spoke about what Alisa’s gift meant to
the Israeli people: “Today, her heart beats in Jerusalem.”
After Alisa’s death, the Flatows lives were shattered. Alisa’s mother
withdrew into herself and her home. But her father Stephen decided to
take action. He wanted justice. It was widely reported that the State of
Iran was the sponsor and financial backer of the Palestinian Islamic
Jihad. It angered him that there were no consequences for Iran. They had
funded his daughter’s murderers, and no one was doing anything about
it. The bomber himself was killed. The terrorist ring was being pursued
by Israel. Stephen Flatow decided to take it upon himself to go after
Iran.
A lawyer by training, he sought justice through the courts. He had an
idea. If he and other victims of terror could file suit against Iran,
they could exact punishment on the regime. They would make it costly for
states to sponsor terror, and then maybe Iran would think twice about
doing it again.
But there was a problem. United States law did not allow private
citizens to sue foreign governments. It was expressly forbidden. So
Stephen Flatow went to Washington to change the law. His senator, Frank
Lautenberg, happened to be in Israel at the time of Alisa’s death. He
took a special interest in her family and drafted legislation. Flatow
testified before congress, and even gained the backing of President
Clinton. Congress passed the Anti-Terrorism Act of 1996 to make an
exception to the longstanding rule. In cases of state-sponsored terror,
individual US citizens could sue foreign nations for damages in US
courts. It was the first victory.
It did not last. The courts threw it out. So back to Washington he went
for a new law, one written specifically to override the objections of
the court.
Once again he sued the state of Iran in a US court. But his time, one of
his allies became an adversary. The Clinton administration began to see
Flatow as interfering in national diplomacy. The White House was
against Iran, but they did not want Flatow dictating the terms. So the
U.S. Department of Justice intervened in the case, and actually filed a
brief in support of Iran and against the victims of terror. Once more,
Flatow returned to Congress and this time he got a third law that gave
citizens even more strength to sue foreign governments, this time with
teeth.
Finally, in 1997, he received his judgment. A court ruled in favor of
the Flatows and against Iran. The family was awarded $26 million in
compensatory damages, and over $200 million in punitive damages.
But the issue was hardly over. How do you collect money from a rogue
state? They weren’t paying. Stephen Flatow devised a plan. Since the
United States had ended diplomatic ties with Iran following the rise of
the Ayatollah, the Iranian embassy in Washington and the residence of
the Iranian ambassador have been in control of the United States
Government. The State Department holds them in trust with the goal of
returning them to Iran someday when relations resume. Stephen Flatow now
had a ruling that said the Iranian government owed him $247 million.
He sought possession of the embassy and the residence, property owned by
Iran. The State Department refused. They feared that if the United
States confiscated sovereign property here, our embassies and properties
abroad would become threatened. So instead, they paid Flatow $20
million from US funds with the understanding that the United States
would collect that money from Iran someday.
Stephen Flatow was furious. His goal was not to get money. His goal was
to make Iran pay so they would stop sponsoring terror. He had won in
court and he had received money, but Iran had still not paid one cent.
And this leads to the third chapter of this amazing saga. Stephen Flatow
did not give up. He began to look for other assets in the United States
that were owned by the government of Iran. Officially, there were none.
United States sanctions prohibited Iran from doing any business in the
United States, or for anyone to do business with Iran in the United
States. But Flatow had suspicions that a charitable foundation in New
York was actually a front, laundering money for the Iranian regime.
Why would the Iranians funnel their money through New York? Because the
financial exchanges are there, and you can’t get anything done
internationally without going through New York’s markets. Iran’s
economy, its nuclear weapons development, its sponsorship of Hezbollah
and other jihadists groups – all required moving money across
currencies. They needed a secret foothold in New York. The
Alavi Foundation
was established decades ago by the Shah to promote Iranian culture
abroad. It owned a gleaming skyscraper on 5th Avenue in Manhattan,
between Rockefeller Center and the Museum of Modern Art. Ivan Boesky
used to office there. Stephen Flatow did a lot of digging, and then
filed papers in court demonstrating that the foundation and the building
were secretly operated by the Iranian government. And if they belonged
to the state of Iran,
they were subject to his financial ruling.
(Note: the Government of Iran
has a different opinion.)
Stephen Flatow’s case was a civil matter, but it came to the attention
of a young analyst sitting in a cubicle at the Manhattan District
Attorney’s office. If what Flatow was saying was true, there was some
serious criminal wrongdoing going on. That young analyst’s name was
Eitan Arusy. Before he starting working for the District Attorney, he
served in the Israel Defense Force as a spokesman. He was one of the
first responders to the scene of the carnage on the day that Alisa
Flatow’s bus was bombed. He had a special interest in the case. The
district attorney’s office did their own digging, and came to the same
conclusion as Flatow – the Alavi Foundation was actually a front for
Bank Melli, the State of Iran’s government-owned national bank. But how
did the Iranians do it? How did they get their money in and out of the
United States?
The district attorney’s office soon discovered that two European Banks,
Credit Suisse and Lloyds of London, were moving money and falsifying
documents for the Iranians. When the FBI raided the records of the
charity, they found vast deposits from Credit Suisse and Lloyds. The
banks cooperated with investigators. They provided emails and memos
detailing how they took Iranian money and sent it to the United States
in their own names. Without admitting guilt, Lloyds agreed to pay a fine
of $350 million, and Credit Suisse $536 million.
They were not alone. It was soon discovered that most of the major
European banks were laundering money for the Iranians into the United
States, in direct violation of US law. Barclays Bank settled in 2010,
paying the United States $298 million. In 2012, ING, Standard Chartered,
and HSBC also settled. HSBC agreed to pay $1.9 billion.
Flatow
wasn't exactly floored by these tiny settlements.
Then came the big one. While all these banks were making deals with the
US government, two employees of BNP Paribas became whistleblowers. They
shared with investigators that their bank had laundered tens of billions
of dollars of Iranian money. They had also laundered money for Sudan
while its regime was committing genocide. BNP is the largest bank in
France. This summer you may have seen the news. BNP became the first
bank to admit guilt in laundering money for the Iranian government. They
agreed to pay $8.9 billion in fines to the United States. It was far
and away the largest penalty ever paid by a bank in history.
The New York Times headline said it best: “
A Grieving Father Pulls a Thread that Unravels BNP’s Illegal Deals”.
A dad lost his girl. The hole in his life will never be filled. He
thinks about her every day. He never gives up. He is a small-time
attorney doing title work in New Jersey.
But his tenacity and his grit and his smarts were beyond anyone’s
estimation. This one man in New Jersey uncovered an international
conspiracy of bank fraud
The story is not over. Stephen Flatow is not done. The man who instantly
changed the culture of organ donation is Israel is trying to do the
same here in America. He takes every opportunity to speak to Orthodox
congregations to encourage organ donation. Though the rate of donation
consent in America is strong at 60%, the rate among Flatow’s fellow
Orthodox Jews is only 5%.
He is on a mission to change that. He and his wife have also established a
foundation in Alisa’s name.
They sponsor young Jewish women from around the world to take a
semester of study in Jerusalem. The money they have received in their
fight against Iran is now sponsoring women’s Torah study and the
vitality of the State of Israel.
Flatow has also become a credible voice speaking truth to power, such as in
this anti-Netanyahu op-ed.
And, in the months ahead, he may finally achieve his goal of making Iran
actually pay. A federal judge has the ruled that the assets of the
Alavi Foundation be liquidated. The gleaming office tower in New York
and other properties around America will be sold and the proceeds will
go to the victims of Iranian-sponsored terrorism. That will be Iranian
money. Finally, Iran will pay a price.
All of this because of one man who never quit.
Sort of puts a sewage backup in your basement into perspective, doesn't it?
What do YOU do when things go wrong? Even horribly wrong?
Shabbat Shalom
PS - It is time to start thinking about Pesach - 3 weeks! Browse books and toys here and don't forget the Art of Amazement Haggada — Leader's Edition. You can download a preview
here.
Serious question: how are you going to make next Friday night different from all other nights?
Last week's email about Stephen Flatow* generated a massive response. (If you missed it, his inspiring story is archived 
Why are they shaped like that, and what does hamantashen mean, anyhow?
So what are supposed to do – defeat our enemies by mocking them? Sounds like a 