This is a powerful question and anyone with a heart should be asking it.
Someone else said to me yesterday, "People today who have always lived in freedom cannot appreciate freedom the way that someone can who literally escaped ______ [name an oppressive country] with their lives."
I hear the point. Just this week, a member of my Zoom Talmud group was recounting his escape as a child from Germany to Shanghai and what it felt like on that final leg to America. I heard his story, and I've read many stories, but I haven't lived them.
But these questions from current events and personal experience underscores a more fundamental question that I have about the Pesach Seder.
No matter which Haggadah you use –
Maxwell House traditional,
modern,
rationalized,
simplified,
expanded,
Amazing – I'm pretty sure that you'll be reading the words,
In each and every generation a person is obligated to see himself as if he personally left Egypt.Everyone always likes to ask,
"What's your favorite part of Pesach?" Nothing wrong with that question, it's a fine conversation-starter.
But try also asking this one:
"What's the hardest part of Pesach for you?"We expect the middle of the bell curve to answer "not eating chametz for a week" or "eating matzah for a week."
But my personal answer is,
Trying to fulfill "In each and every generation..."How are you supposed to do that?
And in our particular generation, living through such difficult times for Jews presently, all the more so - how can you feel liberated today?
I believe this is an excellent question for your Shabbat table and encourage you to think about it and discuss it.
It turns out that it's not actually a new question. Remember that other "every generation" line in the Haggadah? "In every generation they try to destroy us..."
Some or most of our deep-thinking commentators lived through times as bad or far worse than today. Not one of them ever suggested cancelling our holiday of Freedom in light of current events.
But some have suggested interpreting Passover as a message and meditation deeper than mere History.
Each element of the Seder - chametz, matzah, maror, 4 cups of wine, etc. - is symbolic of your and my soul-journey in this world and "enslavement" to our bodily needs and desires.
The Chinuch (13th Century) writes (based on the Talmud), "
The yeast in the flour raises itself up and inflates itself [which represents arrogance]. Therefore, we distance ourselves from it, as reflected in the verse, “Every arrogant heart is an abomination to God” (Proverbs 16:5).Rav E. E. Dessler (20th C) writes, "Everything has an inner aspect to it ... The exile in Egypt appears to a normal person as if it was a physical slavery. But a spiritually-oriented person sees that it was a slavery of the soul, and that this was the real cause for physical slavery. In short, we were slaves to the
yetzer hara (bad inclination).... The Torah calls Egypt Mitzrayim, from the root
meitzar, which means “constriction” and “distress.” It also signifies “boundary.”
The rushing out of Egypt represents the reality that negative habits like laziness and arrogance are defeated when one acts with zeal, with alacrity, with focus and determination. When the alarm goes off, an inner voice says, "Hey, how about 5 more minutes? Let's hit the snooze button!" Another voice says, "No way, we have to get up and change the world!" The first voice tries again, "What's the rush? We can change the world in five minutes!" Back and forth you go until it's half an hour later.
What's the solution? As soon as the alarm rings, leap out of bed! That's the moral of rushing out of Egypt and not having time for the dough to rise.
Yeast in the dough represents the yetzer hara in our hearts makes us leavened. - Rashi
That's something to mediate on while eating your matzah.
May you and yours, and I and mine, and all the Jewish People, and all good people, be personally liberated (physically, spiritually and any other way).
Shabbat Shalom and